Courtney Callaway (she/her)

Courtney is the owner of Prime Choice Insurance and its founding agent. She is married to Matthew and together they have two daughters, Alexis & Annalise. Courtney grew up in Norfolk, NE and moved to Omaha, NE in 2013. She spends a lot of her free time completing puzzles or reading; getting through 50 novels a year! Courtney loves to travel and is always looking forward to her next adventure. Courtney is a member of the National Association of Health Underwriters. She also has a deep passion for supporting and helping the Intercultural Senior Center in Omaha. Listen to an interview with Courtney for more insight about her and Prime Choice Insurance.

Phone: (402) 219-3024
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: courtney@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Julia Suckstorf (she/her}

Julia joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2015 and brought nearly ten years of insurance experience with her. Julia grew up in Tilden, NE and continues to live and service customers in the Northeast Nebraska area. Along with being an insurance agent, she is a mother to Tyler and Ellie. They enjoy most anything to do with animals and spending time taking care of their horses, pony, dog, and cats. They are active in 4-H, their local church, and the kids' sports.

Phone: (402) 992-5782
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: julia@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Glory Kathurima (she/her)

Glory joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2018 having several years of previous Medicare insurance experience. Glory was born in Kenya and moved to the U.S. as a young child. She lives in Omaha, NE with her family. Glory loves getting to know the community. She has been welcomed into a thriving African diaspora in the Midwest and is a Connector at the annual Afromaha Festival. In her free time, Glory enjoys reading, playing board games, going to concerts, plays, and museums. She wishes there were enough hours in the day to stay caught up with all of her podcasts and books. Glory finds joy in traveling and exploring new cities, having conversations with people, eating a lovely meal, and resting.

Phone: (402) 881-0779
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: glory@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Deena Jeppesen (she/her)

Deena joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2015 and was previously our Senior Administrative Assistant. She has eight children, with five left in the home. Deena grew up in Norfolk, NE and now lives in Wayne, NE. Deena enjoys working on her rental properties and they enjoy spending their summers camping, and relaxing when they can.

Phone: (402) 644-1385
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: deena@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Brande Beach (she/her)

Brande joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2018. Prior to entering insurance, she served four years in the United States Army as a Patriot Missile Operator. She lives with her fiancé, Charles, and her two children, Jake and Evie. She lives in Yankton, SD and enjoys going to the beach with her family, baking, going to the park, and watching movies.

Phone: (605) 299-2376
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: brande@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Brawn Suelter (she/her)

Brawn joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2018. She lives in Lincoln, NE with her husband, Paul, two sons, Jace and Carter, & two fur babies, Remi and Rocky. Brawn stays busy with her kids' sports and extracurricular activities, which is almost like another full-time job! In her free time, she enjoys traveling, going to sporting events, cooking, and learning new things.

Phone: (402) 413-5705
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: brawn@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Felicia Rath (she/her)

Felicia joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2024. She grew up in Battle Creek, NE and continues to raise her family in the area. Felicia is a busy mother of four kiddos Kiarrah, Kiannah, Kamirah, and Kingston. She enjoys spending time with her kids and watching them do what they love! In her free time, Felicia enjoys being outdoors, spoiling her fur babies, and traveling.

Phone: (402) 644-1130
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: felicia@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Morgan Ruterbories (she/her)

Morgan joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2024. She lives in Polk City, IA with her fiancé Bryan and their cat, Lenny. Morgan grew up in Neligh, Nebraska and went on to receive her bachelor’s degree in mass communications from Wayne State College. In her free time, Morgan loves traveling, attending live concerts, and listening to podcasts and audio books (specifically true crime and fiction tales). Her favorite musician that she has seen live (3 times) is Elton John and his band. She values honesty, kindness, and open communication.

Phone: (515) 207-5115
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: morgan@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Davina O’Hara (she/her)

Davina is excited to return to Prime Choice Insurance, where she can continue making a positive impact by helping her community access quality healthcare through insurance. When she's not guiding others toward the right health plan, you can find her reading tarot cards around Omaha, enjoying time at Linoma, the river, or frolicking in the park with her family. Davina is a proud mom of three, has an amazing partner, and shares her home with two delightfully mischievous dogs.

Phone: (402) 218-1528
Fax: (402) 875-6550
Email: davina@primechoiceins.com
Toll Free: (844) 219-3024

Katie Wynia (she/her)

Katie joined Prime Choice in 2018. She is married to her college sweetheart Jeremy and they have three children, Karla, Owen, and Ally. Katie grew up in Wayne, lived in Oregon and Arizona, then returned to Wayne when it was time to start a family. She finds joy spending time with her children, actively serving on several community boards, volunteer work, community theatre, and crafting.

Email: katie@primechoiceins.com

Kayla Hilkemann (she/her)

Kayla joined Prime Choice Insurance in 2023. She brings almost a decade of "back office" insurance industry knowledge, having previously worked at a large insurance carrier. Kayla grew up in Norfolk and now lives in Wayne with her husband, Tyler, and two sons, Jaxon and Asher. Kayla enjoys spending time with her family, gardening and canning, reading, and listening to true crime podcasts.

Email: kayla@primechoiceins.com

Marissa Hughes (she/her)

Marissa joined Prime Choice in 2021 and works on our Data Administration team. She grew up in Norfolk and in Omaha. Marissa loves to read, do puzzles, travel, and volunteer. Her favorite book is Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell, her favorite recent trip was to San Diego, and her favorite place to volunteer is at AllPlay Complex in Omaha.

Email: marissa@primechoiceins.com

Matthew Callaway (he/him)

Matthew is married to Courtney Callaway and is the Vice President of Prime Choice Insurance. Matthew has a BS in Management Information Systems and a Masters of Business Administration. He is currently employed as a Senior Software Engineer at a local university. He helps with a lot of behind the scenes work and decisions that make the business run, and is Prime Choice Insurance's go-to for technology advice and setup. Matthew is a seemingly endless source of ideas. He is interested in science, space, sports, technology, anthropology, comedy, and music.

Email: matthew@primechoiceins.com